What If Your Toddler Refuses to Take a Newborn Sibling Picture?

If you’re expecting a new baby and you already have a toddler at home, there is a very good chance you’ve already thought about the sibling pictures. Maybe you’ve seen all those beautiful newborn photographs of an older brother or sister gently holding the new baby, and you’re thinking, “That is beautiful, but there is absolutely no way my child is going to do that.”

And you might be right. 😂

Toddlers, especially those around 18 months to 3 years old, are not exactly known for doing something simply because we think it would make a great photograph. They have their own ideas about what they’re going to do, where they’re going to sit, and whether or not they are interested in the tiny new person who has suddenly become the center of everyone’s attention.

Sometimes they don’t want to sit by the baby. Sometimes they don’t want to hold the baby. Sometimes they don’t even want to be near the baby. And if we’re being honest, the harder everyone tries to convince them, the less likely they are to cooperate.

That’s where I come in.

After years of photographing newborns and families, I’ve learned that trying to force a toddler into a sibling photograph is usually the fastest way to turn a beautiful newborn session into a stressful one. I don’t want Mom and Dad spending the session saying, “Please just sit down,” while their toddler gets more frustrated by the minute.

I have a much better way.

We Don’t Have to Make the Toddler Hold the Baby

When I know the older sibling is absolutely not interested in participating, I change the situation rather than trying to change the child.

Mom or Dad sits right next to the older sibling…sometimes very, very close. If your toddler needs to be touching you, leaning against you, or simply knowing that you’re right there, that’s completely fine. We aren’t trying to make them independent for the sake of a photograph. We’re trying to make them comfortable.

Then we put something in the baby’s spot.

It might be a favorite toy, a snack, a phone playing a favorite video, or something else that keeps your child’s attention. I have even used whatever little thing happens to be working that day. The goal isn’t to trick the child into doing something they don’t want to do. The goal is simply to give them a reason to be happy and comfortable in the right place.

And here’s the important part: there is no baby in the bed yet.

I photograph the older sibling exactly as they are—happy, comfortable, and sitting beside Mom or Dad. If they’re watching a video, eating a little snack, or playing with a favorite toy, that’s perfectly fine. I’m not looking for a perfectly posed toddler. I’m looking for a photograph that I can use to create the final sibling portrait.

Toddler sitting beside parent during a stress-free newborn sibling photo session in Olympia, Washington.

Then I photograph the newborn separately.

Sleeping newborn baby photographed separately for a newborn sibling portrait in Olympia, Washington.

Then I Put the Two Photographs Together

Once I have the photograph of the older sibling and the photograph of the newborn, I combine them into one finished image.

This is something I do regularly, and my whole goal is to make the final photograph look natural. I pay attention to positioning, perspective, lighting, shadows, and all of the little details that make the two photographs work together.

The final image looks like the older sibling is sitting sweetly beside the new baby, even though the toddler was actually sitting next to Mom or Dad with a favorite toy, snack, or video keeping them happy.

And honestly? I don’t care if your toddler knows.

I care that your toddler had a good experience.

I care that your newborn was safe.

I care that Mom and Dad weren’t stressed out trying to convince a two-year-old to cooperate.

And I care that you walked away with the beautiful sibling photograph you wanted.

Toddler sitting beside sleeping newborn baby in a beautiful newborn sibling portrait in Olympia, Washington.

Why I Prefer This Approach

There is a reason I use this technique so often. The photograph is important, but the experience of getting the photograph is important too.

A newborn session is already a big day for a family. You have a brand-new baby who needs to eat, sleep, and be comfortable, and you have an older child who may be trying to figure out what exactly just happened to their world. The last thing I want to do is add unnecessary stress.

If your toddler is perfectly happy sitting beside Mom while watching a favorite video, why would I take that away from them? If they need a snack to stay content, let’s give them a snack. If they want their favorite stuffed animal, bring it along.

I’m not interested in making a toddler “perform” for the camera.

I’m interested in creating a photograph that captures this incredibly important moment in your family’s story while allowing your children to be children.

Your Toddler Does Not Have to Cooperate Perfectly

This is one of the biggest things I want parents to understand before their newborn session. Your toddler does not have to be perfectly behaved. They don’t have to smile on command, sit completely still, or suddenly become interested in newborn photography.

They are allowed to have opinions. They’re allowed to get bored. They’re allowed to need Mom or Dad. They’re allowed to take a break.

And if they absolutely, positively decide that they are not holding the baby, that’s okay too.

Sometimes we get a traditional sibling photograph because the child is happy to participate. Sometimes we capture a completely natural moment. And sometimes we use this technique to create the sibling portrait without asking the older child to do something they simply don’t want to do.

There is no single right way to photograph siblings.

The right way is the way that works for your children.

The Goal Is More Than Just Getting the Picture

I could spend an enormous amount of time trying to get the “perfect” sibling photograph. We could negotiate with a toddler, take breaks, try again, make silly noises, offer rewards, and keep going until everyone is exhausted.

But why?

I would much rather use my experience and a little photography magic to make the process easier.

Because when you look back at your newborn session years from now, I don’t want your strongest memory to be how difficult it was to get your toddler to sit beside the baby.

I want you to remember how tiny your newborn was. I want you to remember how little your older child was. I want you to remember everyone laughing and having a good time. I want your toddler to remember getting special attention from Mom and Dad and having a fun day at the studio.

And yes, I want you to have that beautiful sibling photograph hanging on your wall.

Years from now, your children won’t care how the photograph was created. They’ll simply see themselves together at the very beginning of their relationship.

And that’s what makes these photographs so special.

Frequently Asked Questions About Newborn Sibling Photos

What if my toddler absolutely refuses to hold the baby?
That’s completely okay. I never want to force a toddler to hold a newborn. If traditional sibling posing isn’t working, I can use this technique to create a beautiful sibling portrait while keeping your toddler comfortable.

Is the baby actually next to the toddler in these photographs?
When I use this particular technique, the older sibling is photographed separately from the newborn. I photograph the baby safely on their own and then combine the two images into one finished portrait.

Is this safe for my newborn?
Yes. One of the benefits of this approach is that the newborn is photographed separately rather than relying on an unpredictable toddler to hold or interact with the baby.

What if my toddler won’t cooperate at all?
That’s okay. I don’t expect toddlers to behave like little professional models. We’ll take breaks, change activities, let them be themselves, and work with what they’re comfortable doing that day.

What ages do you use this technique with most often?
I use it most frequently with toddlers around 18 months to 3 years old, although it can be useful with any child who isn’t comfortable participating in a traditional sibling pose.

Can we still try a traditional sibling photograph?
Absolutely. If your child is comfortable holding or sitting near the baby, we’ll photograph that too. This technique is simply another option when traditional sibling posing isn’t working.

Don’t Stress About the Sibling Pictures

If you’re expecting a new baby and already thinking, “There is absolutely no way my toddler is going to take a picture with the baby,” take a deep breath.

You’re not the first parent to tell me that, and you won’t be the last.

I’ve spent years photographing newborns and families, and I know that sometimes the best photographs come from being flexible and finding a solution that works for the child in front of my camera.

Your toddler doesn’t need to cooperate perfectly. Your newborn doesn’t need to be put in an uncomfortable situation. And you don’t need to spend your newborn session stressed out trying to make a photograph happen.

I’ll handle that part.

My goal is to create beautiful newborn sibling photos while keeping your baby safe, your toddler comfortable, and your family relaxed enough to actually enjoy the experience.

Because when you leave the studio, I want you to have two things: beautiful photographs and happy memories of making them.

If you’re expecting a new baby and would love newborn and sibling portraits that are relaxed, thoughtful, and created around your family, I’d love to help you plan your session.

Fairies & Frogs Photography is located in Olympia, Washington, and specializes in newborn photography and portraits for growing families.

Please visit my website for package and pricing information or contact me if you have any questions at all 😊

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *